7 Comments
User's avatar
Sarah Fay, PhD's avatar

How do you create a vibrant comments culture on your Substack?

Expand full comment
Kristin Fellows's avatar

I'm serializing three memoirs on Substack simultaneously. (That's a little crazy, I know.)

And what has consistently surprised me in the comments I get is how something I mention that's happened to me triggers a memory for someone else. And they tell me about it. They're not just reading my stories, they are re-living some of their own lives as they do. And they want to tell me about their own experiences. That's what I love about Substack, because you wouldn't get this same kind of interaction if someone was just reading a book. You'd rarely, if ever, hear their thoughts. With Substack, the audience is right there in front of you. And if your writing resonates, they want to tell you right away about it. I love that.

Expand full comment
Renée Eli, Ph.D.'s avatar

Thank you, Sarah, David, and Gregory. I resonated with all of this. I do not have the numbers that David and Gregory have, not by a longshot. I often hear from readers that they want to linger in silence after the essays. When people do comment, they tend to have a lot to share. I set aside a good chunk of time to meet them at the depth they offer. I would add that engaging readers at this level builds another layer of trust. I was struck by your comments, Sarah, about vertical structure vs. building community.

Expand full comment
Lucy Celebrates's avatar

Thank you for this! My biggest takeaways are consistency in content and building a community, which is exactly my goal! I've established a rhythm of blocking out time to respond to comments and while it's definitely a commitment, it’s so worth it. Those little things build meaningful connections, which is the very thing that I love about Substack.

Expand full comment
Books & Brew 🎀's avatar

I'm lucky that I've come across this video :)

Expand full comment
Bernardette Hernández's avatar

I love David’s Substack, have to check out Gregory’s!

Expand full comment
Sarah Fay, PhD's avatar

Both are so, so good.

Expand full comment